
Dusty Baker with the Dodgers. Such a cool photo.
The ballot for the 2027 Contemporary Baseball Era Committee has been released. This ballot focuses on managers and executives, so it's not very exciting. Let's take a look at the 8 candidates in alphabetical order.
Sandy Alderson: he was the general manager of the Oakland A's from 1983 to 1997, overseeing the team's renaissance and three straight World Series appearances from 1988-1990. Alderson was also general manager of the New York Mets from 2011-2018, including their World Series appearance in 2015. He's also worked for the Padres and the commissioner's office.
Alderson has certainly had a solid career as an MLB executive. I really don't have strong feelings about whether or not Alderson should be in the Hall of Fame. He's not a slam dunk case.
Dusty Baker: Baker had 13 seasons of 90+ wins in 26 years as a manager. 24 seasons if you discount 1994 and 2020, seasons when it would have been impossible to win 90 games. Baker is 8th all-time in managerial wins, with 2,183, and his winning percentage of .540 is higher than Connie Mack, Tony LaRussa, Joe Torre, and Bruce Bochy, all of whom have more wins than Baker. Baker has a great case for the Hall, and he would be the first Black manager elected to the Hall of Fame. I think Baker will definitely be elected by the committee.
Also, Dusty Baker has one of the coolest baseball names of all-time. And he is a co-inventor of the high five. He met Jimi Hendrix. He was friends with Henry Aaron. Baker had a solid career as a player, making his debut with the Braves in September 1968 at age 19. It was 1972 before Baker broke through as an everyday player, but he had a great season, hitting .321, good for 3rd in the NL. Baker was traded from the Braves to the Dodgers after the 1975 season, and one of the players the Braves got in return was Lee Lacy, meaning the trade involved two of the greatest baseball player names of that era.
Baker had good power, slugging 242 home runs over his career, with a peak of 30 in 1977. That year, the Dodgers became the first MLB team to have four players hit 30 or more home runs in a season: Baker, Ron Cey, Reggie Smith, and Steve Garvey. In the 1977 NLCS, Baker slugged two home runs and collected 8 RBI's and was named the NLCS MVP. Baker was a solid postseason player, collecting 42 hits over 40 postseason games, including 5 home runs and 21 RBI's, with a .282 batting average and a .341 OBP.
Bruce Bochy: Bochy is 6th on the list of most wins by a manager, with 2,252. Add in 4 World Series championships, and Bochy is a shoo-in for the Hall of Fame, despite having a record that is 14 games under .500.
When I was a kid, I would mix up Bruce Bochy and Bruce Bochte, due to their extremely similar names. Bochte had the better playing career, as he played 12 years as an everyday player, and Bochy was always a backup catcher. Bochte was even an All-Star in 1979, and hit an RBI single off of Gaylord Perry in the All-Star Game. Bochte took a year off of baseball in 1983, then came back for three more seasons with the Oakland A's, putting him on a short list of players who voluntarily retired and then returned to the game—Ryne Sandberg is the only other player who comes to my mind. Bochte was always a deep thinker, and after his retirement from baseball, he studied the relationship between humans and the environment, the history of the universe, and all sorts of things. Bochte worked for the California Institute of Integral Studies as Director of the Center for the Story of the Universe.
Dusty Baker was a teammate of Bochte's on the Oakland A's, and in a 2023 profile of Bochte he had high praise for his friend: "I love Bruce. Bruce and I used to talk about philosophy and a lot of things. Bruce was the one that explained to me about the Western shelf and the earthquakes."
But I digress. Bruce Bochy will surely be voted into the Hall of Fame.
Joe Maddon: With 1,382 wins, Maddon ranks 32nd in manager wins. Maddon had success in Tampa Bay, and of course won the 2016 World Series with the Cubs. Maddon doesn't have enough wins to be a lock for the Hall of Fame, and his career winning percentage of .532 is fine, but not spectacular. Maddon has 10 more wins than Davey Johnson, but Johnson had a much better winning percentage, .562 to .532. I don't think there's any reason to pick Maddon for the Hall above Baker, Bochy, and Lou Piniella.
Lou Piniella: "Sweet Lou" won 1,835 games, good for 17th place. The only managers with more wins who aren't in the Hall of Fame are Baker and Bochy, who will both probably get in with this vote, Terry Francona, who is still active, and Gene Mauch. That bodes well for Piniella, who has come close to being elected in past committee votes. I think Piniella should probably get in, but it might not be this time, since Baker and Bochy will gather more votes. Speaking of Gene Mauch, what does the Hall of Fame have against him? Sure, Mauch's winning percentage was under .500, and he never made it to the World Series, but he was a great manager who did the most with the talent he was given.
Brian Sabean: He was the general manager of the Giants from 1997 to 2014, and during his tenure the Giants won three World Series. Is that enough to get into the Hall of Fame? Beats me.
Ted Turner: Why is Ted Turner even on this ballot? Turner was such a loon when he bought the Braves in 1976, but he was the owner for the start of the team's dynasty of the 1990's. Turner even famously managed the Braves for one game in 1977. (They lost.) His influence on baseball and TV viewership was huge because he started TBS to broadcast Braves games. Thanks to Turner, the Braves developed a strong regional and national fanbase in the 1980's and 1990's. I never had cable TV as a kid. After my parents got divorced, my dad got basic cable in his apartment. That meant we got TBS and WGN, so we could watch Braves and Cubs games. This was a big deal in the late 1980's and early 1990's, before there were as many options for watching baseball on TV. Watching TBS didn't make me a Braves fan, but I thank Ted Turner for his vision. And I also thank Ted Turner for being a billionaire who donated money to the United Nations, and believed in land conservation, rather than just leading vanity projects to launch penis-shaped rockets to Mars. But does Ted Turner deserve to be in the Hall of Fame? Turner himself said it best in 1996: "For the 10 years I ran {the team}, it was a disaster. As I relinquished control of the Braves and gave somebody else the responsibility, it did well." So, I'd say no.
Bill White: White has had a long and successful career in MLB. He was a great first baseman in the 1960's, a 7-time Gold Glove winner. White was a broadcaster for the New York Yankees, and then was President of the National League from 1989 to 1994. White was named the HOF's Buck O'Neil Lifetime Achievement Award winner in 2026, and that seems like a better prize for him than being recognized solely for his five-year stint as President of the NL. White is a difficult case because he did so many different things in his career. I've always liked Bill White; he was in a book I thumbed through a lot as a kid that had lifetime statistics of lots of great baseball players. I'm not sure exactly why the editors picked Bill White for the book, but they did. He's one of those baseball players I feel like I know well, even though he played long before I was born.
If I had a vote on this committee, I would vote for Dusty Baker and Bruce Bochy, and it's my prediction that the committee will elect Baker and Bochy.
