2025 Classic Baseball Era Committee Results

Dick Allen, about to give a baseball a ride.

Dave Parker, with a hat full of stars.

Yesterday, Dave Parker and Dick Allen were elected to the Baseball Hall of Fame by the Classic Baseball Era Committee. 12 votes were needed for election, Parker received 14, and Allen received 13. Tommy John got 7 votes, and the other candidates, Ken Boyer, John Donaldson, Steve Garvey, Vic Harris, and Luis Tiant all received fewer than 5 votes. I’m disappointed that Tommy John didn’t get in, but I’m very happy about Parker and Allen being elected, and that my prediction was half correct.  

Allen and Parker were two of the best baseball players not in the Hall of Fame, and I think they make worthy additions to Cooperstown. Allen had come heartbreakingly close to induction, falling just one vote short of induction on two previous Veterans’ Committee ballots. Unfortunately, Allen passed away in December of 2020. Dave Parker is still with us, fortunately, and I’m so glad that he gets to enjoy the thrill of being a Hall of Famer.  

There have been various Veterans’ Committees in the history of the Baseball Hall of Fame. The Veterans’ Committee justly gets a bad rap for the many borderline candidates they elected during the 1960’s and 1970’s, and even into the 1980’s—Travis Jackson, George Kell, and Rick Ferrell, I’m looking at you! Since 2018, the Eras Committees have elected a number of outstanding players that the baseball writers totally whiffed on: Alan Trammell, Lee Smith, Ted Simmons, Gil Hodges, Minnie Minoso, Jim Kaat, Tony Oliva, Fred McGriff, and now Dick Allen and Dave Parker. You can quibble with Jack Morris and Harold Baines if you want to, but I think they’re worthy additions as well. This is proof that the Veterans’ Committee/Eras Committee is working the way it should: adding deserving players to the Hall of Fame that were overlooked by the writers.  

Now I need to write up my thoughts on the 2025 BBWAA ballot. I have a sneaking suspicion that Allen and Parker will be joined by at least one other inductee next July. (Spoiler alert: it’s Ichiro!)  

2024 Baseball Hall of Fame Contemporary Era Committee Results

Jim Leyland, sneaking a smoke in the dugout with the Tigers.

Yesterday the Contemporary Baseball Era committee met and elected Jim Leyland to the Baseball Hall of Fame. In my post last week, I predicted the committee might elect more than one man from the ballot, but that didn’t happen. Lou Piniella was named on 11 of 16 ballots, missing election by just one vote. Bill White received 10 votes, and none of the other men on the ballot received more than 5 votes.  

I’m not surprised that Leyland was elected, he was a great manager who managed a lot of excellent teams over his career. I was a little surprised that Piniella wasn’t elected as well, but since he’s come so close to getting elected, I think he will get in one of these times. I think it would be cool to have Bill White in the Hall of Fame, but it seems a little odd to elect him as an executive since he only spent 5 years in that role. I think baseball should have some kind of “overall excellence” Hall of Fame they could put people in. I was thinking of something similar for Lefty O’Doul when he was on an Era Committee ballot in 2021. O’Doul’s career was really too short to elect him to the Hall of Fame as a player, but he also managed in the Pacific Coast League for 22 years after his playing career. But the Baseball Hall of Fame doesn’t honor minor league managers. So, there’s not much of a path for O’Doul to get into the Hall of Fame. Bill White falls into a similar category. White was an excellent player, but not quite great enough for the Hall of Fame. White was then an announcer for the Yankees from 1971 to 1988, a distinguished run, but not worth of Hall entry on its own. Perhaps those figures in baseball who don’t quite fit in the other categories should be eligible for this imaginary “overall excellence” Hall of Fame wing.  

I was also shocked that umpire Joe West didn’t get elected to the Hall of Fame. West has umpired more games than anyone else in MLB history. What more do you want from an umpire?  

Stay tuned for my upcoming post in December where I profile the candidates on the BBWAA Hall of Fame ballot.  

Dave Parker: 200 Baseball Cards

 

Dave Parker was one of the coolest baseball players of the 1970’s and 1980’s. I’ve always liked Parker, and I wrote about the 2019 documentary about him “The Cobra at Twilight.” I recently bought a lot of 200 of Dave Parker’s baseball cards. There were many duplicates, but this lot helped me fill in a lot of the gaps in my Parker collection.

Listed at 6’5” and 230 pounds, Parker was an intimidating presence at the plate, and he used his powerful frame to crank out 2,712 hits, 339 home runs, and 1,493 RBIs over a 19-season MLB career. Parker had a powerful throwing arm, and he was regarded as one of the best defensive right fielders during his prime.

It fits that someone as cool as Dave Parker would also have some cool baseball cards. Here are some of my favorites from the lot I bought.

Dave Parker, 1982 Fleer Stamps. Dave is with Steve Carlton on the right.

1982 Fleer Stamps: I’ve always loved the Pirates’ hats of that era, especially with “Stargell Stars” on them. The photo of Dave and Steve Carlton is so cool. It’s most likely taken at the 1981 All-Star Game. Based on what I know about Dave Parker’s personality, he was probably ribbing Steve about something. “Hey man, how come you don’t talk to the press? I love talking to the press! I talk to them all day long!” And Steve’s probably saying, “Oh, I talk to them, I just don’t let them quote me.” I’m glad I didn’t have to pitch to Dave Parker, and I’m glad I didn’t have to bat against Steve Carlton. Two of the best players and most intense competitors of their era.

Dave Parker, 1982 Topps All-Star. Those Pirates uniforms were so cool.

1982 Topps All-Star: This card shows Parker giving an interview, as we can see the microphone he’s speaking into. As a kid, I always found these cards where you can see players being interviewed interesting. I guess what intrigued me is that these cards hint at the larger world—there are other people besides the Topps photographer who want to talk to this baseball player. What’s cool about Parker’s 1982 card is that you can see his pierced ear. Woah, it’s 1982 and this dude has a pierced ear?? That’s bad ass.

Dave Parker, 1987 Fleer Mini and regular size. I really like that the Minis featured different photos than the base cards.

The back of Parker's 1987 Fleer cards. The full size card says he's a "dead pull hitter," while the mini card correctly says he's a "power hitter."

1987 Fleer mini and regular size: By the time these cards came out, Parker had suffered through a few years in the wilderness in the early 1980’s, marred by drug addiction and diminishing power. When Parker became a free agent after the 1983 season, the Pirates made little effort to re-sign him. The consensus was that Parker was overpaid, as he was making a hefty $1 million dollars a year. Parker signed with his hometown Cincinnati Reds and turned his career around. Parker posted career highs in home runs and RBIs in 1985, and finished 2^nd in the MVP vote. The Cobra was back. Fleer made 120-card mini versions of their sets for 3 years: 1986, 1987, and 1988. To me, what makes the mini-Fleers so cool is that they used a different photo of the player than the full-sized card. It shows that some extra thought went into them. I love the 1987 Fleer design, with the blue borders. Although now that I look at these cards, I wonder why they faded the border to white on the bottom half of the card, rather than keeping it that same blue all the way around. For 1987, Fleer classified batters as “singles hitters,” “spray hitters,” which we all knew was just another term for “singles hitters,” “dead pull hitters,” whatever that was, and “power hitters,” which we all knew was the best category. What’s interesting is that Dave Parker has two different classifications. On the full-size card, he’s listed as a “dead pull hitter.” But the mini card knows what’s up and changed Parker’s classification to “power hitter.” That’s more like it.

Dave Parker, 1987 Fleer Award Winners. Dave won the "Sports Writers Batting Award," otherwise known as a Silver Slugger.

1987 Fleer Award Winners: This is one of those cards from the 1980’s that I missed at the time. Fleer Award Winners was a 44-card set distributed at 7-11 stores. It features a great picture of a smiling Parker and informs us that he won something called the “Sports Writers Batting Award.” I think this must refer to Parker being named a Silver Slugger for 1986. Other players in the set won the “Sports Writers Fielding Award,” which means they won a Gold Glove. Fleer must not have paid for the rights to use the trademarked name for the awards.

1991 Upper Deck. Dave Parker swinging a sledgehammer would be very intimidating.

1991 Upper Deck: Parker spent 1988 and 1989 with the Oakland A’s and made it to 2 World Series with them. During the 1989 off-season, Parker was signed as a free agent by the Milwaukee Brewers. Parker played only one year with the Brewers, but he had a fine season in 1990, rapping out 176 hits, slugging 21 home runs, and driving in 92 runs. Parker was named to the All-Star team and won the Silver Slugger award at DH. During spring training in 1991, Parker was dealt from the Brewers to the Angels. Parker’s Upper Deck card shows him in the on-deck circle, swinging a sledgehammer. As though a 6’5” Parker swinging a wooden bat wasn’t a terrifying enough sight for pitchers to behold.

1992 Upper Deck. This was Parker's last baseball card, and the only card that shows him with the Blue Jays.

1992 Upper Deck: Parker’s production finally fell off during 1991, his age 40 season. Through 501 plate appearances with the Angels, Parker was hitting a dismal .232 with only 11 home runs when they released him on September 7^th. A week later, Parker was picked up by the Blue Jays. It was too late to add Parker to the post-season roster, but he still provided some punch down the stretch, as he banged out 12 hits over his 13 games with the Blue Jays, good for a .333 batting average and a .400 OBP. That would prove to be the end of Dave Parker’s MLB career. A free agent once the season ended, he got an offer from the Phillies to be a part-time player but chose to retire. Upper Deck was the only card company to give Parker a card for 1992, and it’s a cool card, even if it’s slightly jarring to see Parker as a Blue Jay.

Dave Parker, "The Cobra at Twilight"

 

Proof that Dave Parker was a serious badass.

Dave Parker winning the MVP Award for the 1979 All-Star Game.

Dave Parker with his hometown Cincinnati Reds.

I’ve liked Dave Parker for a long time. I wasn’t around for the Cobra’s 1975-1980 heyday, but by the time I started following baseball in 1986-87, he was one of those cool veteran players who seemed larger than life. You know, one of those players whose stat line filled the whole back of the baseball card, leaving no room for extra nuggets of information.

I recently watched the 2019 MLB documentary “The Cobra at Twilight,” an excellent look at Parker’s life and career. Parker was diagnosed with Parkinson’s Disease in 2013, and the film shows Parker going to the gym and doctor’s appointments. The contrast between Parker’s imposing strength during his prime and how tough it is for him to get around now is sad. However, it’s obvious from the film that Parker’s spirit remains strong.

When I was a kid staring at the back of his baseball cards, Dave Parker’s stats seemed enormous to me: 339 home runs! 1,493 RBI’s! Wow! At the time Parker retired after the 1991 season, he was 32^nd on the all-time list in RBI’s and tied for 47^th on the home run list. He’s now 58^th in RBI’s and tied for 102^nd in home runs.

As I started to follow the Hall of Fame voting more closely, I always thought that Parker was underappreciated by the BBWAA. For the 15 years Parker was on the BBWAA ballot, his highest vote total was 24.5% in 1998, his second year on the ballot. Parker was a player who was regarded as an elite power hitter during his career, but by the time he hit the Hall of Fame ballot, 339 home runs didn’t seem as amazing.

Because Parker didn’t walk a lot, sabermetric stats haven’t helped his Hall of Fame case. Parker’s excellence is captured in the main hitting stats found on the back of his baseball card. Sabermetrics aren’t kind to Parker’s fielding, despite his reputation during his career as an excellent right fielder. The sabermetric community hasn’t taken up Parker’s case with the same fervor that they’ve adopted Tim Raines and Bert Blyleven, to name two contemporaries of Parker’s who saw their vote totals soar and were eventually elected by the BBWAA.

Looking at Parker’s WAR you can see some of the limitations of WAR as a statistic. Look at Parker’s 1986 season. He appeared in all 162 games for the Reds, smacked 174 hits, with 31 doubles, 31 home runs, 116 RBIs, and a .273 batting average. Parker’s OPS+ was 117, and he led the league in total bases with 304. He was 10^th in the NL in slugging, 7^th in hits, tied for 2^nd in home runs, 2^nd in RBIs, and 4^th in extra base hits. According to WAR, that season was worth 0.3 WAR. Parker’s offensive WAR for the year was 2.1, but his defensive WAR was -2.5, which negated most of his value. So, 0.3 WAR means that you could have taken any schlub off the bench at AAA, plugged him into the lineup and he would have produced as well as Parker would have. Okay, I’ll take the leading slugger from the 1986 Denver Zephyrs, Lloyd McClendon. Did McClendon ever hit 30 home runs and have 100 RBIs in the majors? Well, Lloyd did hit 35 home runs and drive in 154 runs, but that was over his entire 570 game major league career. It’s not that easy to replace the Cobra, WAR!

Since his final appearance on the BBWAA ballot in 2011, Parker has appeared on several Era Committee ballots, and I’ve written about Parker in 2017 and 2019. Parker hasn’t been elected to the Hall of Fame yet, but in 2019 he was named on 7 of 16 ballots, falling just 5 votes short of election. For as much as these small committees have been criticized over the years, they’ve also made some excellent selections recently: Ron Santo, Alan Trammell and Ted Simmons, three players who were wrongly overlooked by the BBWAA.

Much like Steve Garvey, Dave Parker has the “fame” part of the Hall of Fame covered. Parker was a 7-time All-Star, won 2 batting titles, was the 1978 NL MVP, won 3 Gold Gloves, had an amazing 1979 All-Star Game, where he threw out two baserunners and was voted MVP, and played on 2 World Series Champion teams a decade apart—the 1979 Pirates and the 1989 Oakland A’s.

At his peak, from 1975-1980, Dave Parker was one of the best players in baseball. As a measure of how contemporary baseball writers viewed him, Parker was listed in the 1981 edition of The 100 Greatest Baseball Players of All Time, by Lawrence Ritter and Donald Honig. Ritter and Honig were taking a huge gamble when they chose players who were not even halfway through their careers for the 1981 edition of the book, but it says something about Parker’s stature in the game that he was viewed as an all-time great by two very respected baseball writers and historians. When Ritter and Honig updated their book in 1986, Parker was one of the players who was removed from the book. Other players who Ritter and Honig had second thoughts about were George Foster, Fred Lynn, and Tony Oliva. It also says something about how far Parker’s star had fallen that he didn’t make the 1986 edition.

In the early 1980’s, Dave Parker was clearly a star in decline. Injuries cost him much of the 1982 season, and it seemed like much of the power had been drained from the Cobra’s bat. What we later learned was that Parker had a cocaine problem during the early 80’s. After the 1983 season, Parker signed as a free agent with his hometown Cincinnati Reds, and he came roaring back with a terrific year in 1985. As his drug problems made headlines, Parker was able to maintain focus on the game, and led the NL in doubles, RBI, and total bases, finishing 2^nd in the MVP voting behind Willie McGee.

Dave Parker was a hugely self-confident player, and the film likens him to Muhammad Ali. Whereas now Parker’s braggadocio might look less out of place, in the 1970’s, it was still something of a rarity for a Black player to be so outspoken. Did that influence how the media of the time covered Parker? I’m sure it did.

Parker was very different from the Pirates’ other Black superstars. Roberto Clemente was the humble, graceful, quiet star. (Even so, the press of the time often portrayed him as a hypochondriac.) And Willie Stargell was the chubby and loveable clubhouse leader. Parker was more in the Reggie Jackson mold, telling reporters, “When the leaves turn brown, I’ll be wearing the batting crown.”

“The Cobra at Twilight” tells us that things really changed for Parker after he signed a huge contract during the 1978-79 off-season. The deal averaged out to a little more than a million dollars a year, although some of that was deferred. Adjusted for inflation, that would be like paying Parker $3.6 million a year in 2021 dollars, which would be a steal. Once a player gets a huge contract, it’s easy for the fans to resent them. Especially when Parker gained a bunch of weight. Then it’s easy to paint that player as “lazy” and “unmotivated.” Fans threw batteries and even a bullet at Parker in right field. I was shocked to see some of the editorial cartoons of Parker that ran in Pittsburgh papers at the time. The drawings were racist and insulting.

It’s hard not to want just a little more from Dave Parker’s stats. He was such a great player that you can’t help but want the numbers to be a little bigger. According to Baseball-Reference, over 162 games, Parker averaged 178 hits, 22 home runs, and 98 RBI’s. So, what would happen if we gave Parker his 162-game average for his mid-career decline? I know, this is getting into speculative territory, but stay with me here. I’m not giving Parker extra seasons or theorizing what his stats would be if he could have hit 40 home runs every season he played. Let’s just look at his seasons from 1980-84, plus 1976, the one off-year during his peak. These stats assume that Parker doesn’t get injured, and that there’s no players strike in 1981, so a full season would have been played that year.

So, if Parker could have just played to his 162-game average during those 6 seasons, what career numbers would he have ended up with?

Hits: move from 2,712 to 3,004

HR: move from 339 to 399

RBI: move from 1,493 to 1,686

Obviously, if Parker had those numbers, he’d be a first-ballot Hall of Famer. And really, we can forget about homers and RBIs: once he moves over the 3,000-hit threshold, he would have been in. And you probably don’t have to mess with 6 seasons like I did to get Parker in the Hall. If there’s no players strike in 1981, and he has a decent 1982 season and doesn’t get hurt, let’s add 100 hits to each of those seasons. Now he’s at 2,912 hits. Let’s not even adjust his other numbers. Okay, we’ll give him 10 more RBI, so he gets over 1,500. Does he get into the Hall of Fame with 2,912 hits, 339 home runs, and 1,503 RBI? I would think so.

I know that’s all speculation, but to me it shows how close to being a first-ballot Hall of Famer Dave Parker was. And personally, I would just like to see Dave Parker in the Hall of Fame. Dave Parker was cool. He was a 6’5” badass who had a pierced ear and wore a Star of David. His answer to why he wore it was simple: “My name’s David and I’m a star.” The Hall of Fame would simply be a little cooler if Dave Parker were in it.